Abstract:
This article was about the correlation between diversity and learning styles. It highlighted the research done to examine the similarities and differences between cultures and learning styles. In this article there is the controversy of assuming that students with the same culture are going to have the same learning styles but that it could lead to stereotyping. The idea of knowing each student, including their background and culture is emphasized because of the importance in using several different teaching strategies. Guild did a study observing Mexican Americans, African Americans, Native Americans, and white Americans. She notes how there was a link between members of each group and their learning styles. For example, most Native Americans preferred quiet time in the classroom, while most African Americans preferred group discussions. Several differing opinions are then offered on approaching culture as it pertains to learning. Some believe that it should be a key component of differentiation, others feel that overestimation of this aspect could distract from other fundamentals of education. As the debate continues, the important thing to remember is that all children learn differently, whether due to culture or just individually and as teachers we much accommodate for all those different styles.
Reflection:
As a class we all seemed to feel that the article bordered on the offensive when it implied that members of certain cultures will all behave the same and have the same learning styles. While we did agree that there are general commonalities that can sometimes be assumed, we thought it presumptuous to place such stereotypical stigmas on the students. Many of us also thought the overall message of the article a little stale. That is, we as future educators are aware that our students have different learning styles, and that this is not just due to the fact that they have different cultural backgrounds, but that every individual is unique and thus their learning styles are equally unique and different from one another. Many of us also picked up on the suggestion that schools be segregated by culture and found the idea rather alarming and very outdated. Despite these differences in agreement and rather negative reactions, there were a few positive associations and one issue that everyone seemed to agree on with the article. The first being that we as teachers need to be aware that our students have different learning styles and perhaps even different cultural backgrounds and emphasis than us. The other idea, that everyone picked up on was that education seems to do things “all or nothing.” When one idea is presented that is logical and relevant they throw all their resources and energy into enacting that one idea, ignoring all the other useful and helpful ideas that have also worked. the article, and we as a class agree, states that we cannot throw all our eggs into one basket, we must use a combination of things to find what works best for our students.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

2 comments:
Oh boy. I think the introduction to the How to Teach English article is very interesting. I love that they start out with something about using the textbook and handing out worksheets. You are never going to reach a variety of students if you simply teach from the textbook and hand out worksheets. I am taking a religion class right now on campus. The professor never uses textbooks because she believes that if we wanted to learn about a subject in a textbook we could order it and pick one up and read it on our own. She believes in the importance of using primary texts in order to delve into the subject more. I also think this article is important because learning styles are important.
It was good to read your interpretation of the article, along with a few others, compared to mine. I'm more of a read, synthesis, and move on. Not so much of a criticize type of person. It was good to see some of the stereotyping I didn't see on my own. Your links are really good and seem helpful.
Post a Comment