Thursday, November 20, 2008

Students at Bat Reflection

Abstract:
”Students at Bat” pointed out the numerous ways we take responsibility away from students and then become frustrated when they won’t take responsibility the few times we allow. It explores who, parents or educators, should be the ones to instill this very important skill in students, and ways in which we teachers can provide students with opportunities to step up and take responsibility during their education. It goes on to say that students are not learning this valuable skill because we take away their learning opportunities and they are not as prepared for life as they should be. They conclude by saying that giving students increased responsibility and choice will help spark more interest in school.
Reflection:
I completely agree with this article. Society as a whole has become more protective of our children, not only in the case of their safety, but this has ended up with us not allowing them to make any mistakes. We decide everything for them, not allowing them to make their own choices to learn how to be responsible, everything is handed to them and there is little value in it.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Personal Philosophy Reflection

As with anything in my life my philosophy will affect how I view things and how I arrange my life. It only makes sense that it would also affect how I intend on running my classroom. I have no set view for how my classroom is going to be organized, and I don’t intend on having a set arrangement, depending on what we are doing and who the students need to interact with is how the classroom will be arranged. Again with discipline and assessment it entirely depends on what the students are doing and what will best reflect their learning or best suit whatever “crime” it is they have done. The same really can be said for all the categories. I don’t intend on having a set way of teaching or of doing anything, I intend to completely tailor it to my students and our curriculum.

Alternative Schools

Alternative schools was the topic for last Thursday’s presentation, and they discussed charter schools, religious schools, and this funky school called Summerhill. There was a lot to discuss as most of us had not even heard of charter schools until enrolling in UMF. There wasn’t a whole lot of time left to discuss Summerhill and what the implications of having a school like that might do for a child’s education, and whether it could work elsewhere. I think it would have been nice to see more on the effects on education these alternative schools have, have they proven more effective, or to turn out more well rounded individuals. Even though I know stats cannot adequately display a child’s learning it’s nice to have something concrete to look at every once in awhile. Other than that it was nice to learn about those alternatives to public school that are out there if only for the simple fact that it’s a topic that I have never explored before.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Voices Reflection

The biggest thing I noticed about Voices is that everyone has a different idea of what an education should entail and how it should be delivered. They mainly fall into two categories—those that wish to revolutionize some form of education and take a radically new approach ( which may in fact be logical and necessary), and those wishing to seemingly go back to the days of Plato with only slight variations. This is of course a great simplification of the many ideas presented, and there were the few completely radical individuals. But for the most part I feel that education and the philosophies have followed a trend of bucking their predecessor’s ideas and thus creating a sort of cyclic effect with no real new changes being exacted because no one has taken the time to try to incorporate everyone’s good ideas into one philosophy. I’ve said it before in blogs and I’ll say it again, no one person and philosophy can solve everything, we need to merge and blend to create a truly diverse ideology. The problem with that is the same with politics, no one seems to want to compromise, it’s all or nothing.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Discipline Presentation Blog

Discipline is a highly controversial subject and this presentation did a very good job of getting across the ambiguity of what discipline is most effective. It was also interesting to see the video on the school that still allowed corporal punishment and the effects it had on that particular school environment. The discussion it generated was also enlightening and well worth the extra time we took. There weren’t any concrete rules or guidelines given, if anything we came away with less solid ideas on what is fair and unfair. And while we may form our own ideas about what equates a just and deserving disciplinary action we are not always guaranteed to have the backing of the school district which may already have a set of rules we are supposed to follow.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Classroom Management Presentation

While the information being delivered in the presentation was not new (we covered many of the same things in Dr. Theresa’s section of block), the resources that accompanied their information was incredibly helpful. I specifically really enjoyed the website that allowed the teacher to manage everything relating to their student’s grades and assignments and how it would automatically e-mail parents their children’s grades if they so chose. I don’t know why more schools don’t use such systems, especially when many of the sites and programs are free to educators and districts. It’s hard to think of things to reflect on, the presentation and information were all flawless, but having heard many things on this subject already, there isn’t much more to say. The highlight was definitely their additional sources for us to take advantage of.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

TWYH pgs 228-265

Abstract:
Erin loses her congressional bid and is absolutely devastated and seemingly no longer knows what to do with her life. Once again she freaks out that she is no longer seeing her freedom writers on an almost daily basis and manages to pull them back to her when she gets a chance to go speak in front of a lot of people about her experiences. Eventually, this turns into a gig for her, so she no longer has to work and can keep her freedom writers near her. She also manages to get a writer to become interested in her story and write a screenplay. Her father passes away when she is on her way to give a speech, and it is shortly after that that she finds out Hilary Swank is going to play her in the movie. She meets her and decides she is perfect and the book comes to a close with the premiere of the movie.
Reflection:
I am so glad this book is done. I didn’t think it was possible but Erin got even more self absorbed in the final section. It also seems to me that she is using her students as a replacement for the husband she lost; she literally breaks down when she has to be separated from her former students. The fact that she finds a way to live her life and never leave them is just really sad to me. She also manages to find a way to support herself monetarily without ever having to accept the fact that maybe she cannot recreate her success with another group of students. I also found her comment about Hilary’s divorce to be rather shallow, about how it would help her understand how she was feeling during that time in her life. I really just had a hard time reading this section, she was so self absorbed.

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

The Four Philosophies

The four philosophies are idealism, realism, pragmatism, and existentialism, and they differ greatly from one another. Idealism stresses the mind and only the mind, if anything exists it is because the mind has made it so. They rely heavily on logic and are always searching for the “ultimate truth.” That is not to say that they believe that everyone can reach this truth, and that the majority of us spend our lives thinking at a much lower level than what we are capable of.
Realism goes in the complete opposite direction as idealism and stresses the natural world and physical objects. Reality is external and not governed by the mind, and that our values and morals are derived from the natural world. Whatever mimics the order of nature is desired
Pragmatism does not deal in absolutes like the previous two philosophies, but rather believes that reality is constantly changing and altering. The arrival of “truths” combines both realism and idealism, by reflecting on scientific testing and retesting. Whatever leads to a desirable outcome is morally correct.
Existentialism rejects all the scientific and reality based theories of the previous philosophies and focuses on personal choice and responsibility. They believe it is our choices that determine reality, and that nothing is set unless we decide it is so.
After reading through all the philosophies there was not one single one that jumped at me as fitting my own beliefs. I could quickly cross of idealism and realism, but there were parts of pragmatism and existentialism that I both emphasized with and absolutely rejected. I agree with the pragmatists about the focus on what we experience, feel, and believe determining what we feel to be good or beautiful. But I do not agree with their focus on testing, questioning and retesting. I do believe in that overall idea to a smaller extent that we need to experience things for ourselves. As for the existentialist beliefs, I agree in personal choice, and that we determine our own realities. But I don’t agree with their belief that we owe nature nothing other than our simple existence, seems rather arrogant.

Tracking Presentation

The educational issue presented in class on Thursday was tracking. Even though there is many negative aspects of tracking I really don’t think the basic ideas behind tracking are all that bad. That does not mean that I believe they have been implemented in positive ways in the vast majority of schools, but I do believe that it can be implemented to the advantage of the students. I don’t think my school had a perfect example of tracking, however, as is not the case in many schools, movement between the tracks was possible and quite common in fact. And it was not all movement to lower tracks, but we had many people join us in the honors classes year after year. Movement was not solely teacher directed either, if a student wanted to change they could begin the process, the teacher did have say still too. This was more to prevent students from dropping into lower tracks just to have an easy time of it I believe. I don’t think tracking needs to be abolished completely, but it most certainly needs to be changed and made sure that the schools are using tracking to the advantage of the students and not to their detriment.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

TWYH pgs 177-227

Abstract:
A lot happens in this section, the students graduate and Erin decides to take a position teaching at a local college. She struggles with feelings of giving up on teaching and being able to let go of her former students. So she doesn’t; she gathers them all together again and they arrange a tour of Europe to the places they read about. Despite trying to raise money elsewhere, she once again turns to John Tu to fund the trip. Several pages are spent detailing their trip to Europe and upon her return she manages to finagle getting all the Writers as the winner of an award and get Doubleday to publish their book. With the award and the book another trip to New York is arranged and more luck falls into Erin’s lap and it eventually ends with her running for congress.
Reflection:
I have no idea what possessed Erin to run for congress, she had never previously expressed an interest in politics or reform other than helping her students, and seemed like she was doing simply because she thought she should win, and because she did so well with her students she would automatically do well with the government. I’m really ready to be done with Erin, she is just starting to annoy me now. I just want to say let go of your students! Let them live their own lives!

School Part 4

This was probably the least surprising and interesting of the series, but that’s simply because I lived it. For the most part I know what happened because I was there. In fact, the biggest shocker was learning that it was Clinton who got us started on the path to standardized testing. So many people blame it on Bush and the republicans that I just never questioned it. It just goes to show that no one party, person, or idea can answer all education’s problems. And it seems sad that we keep trying to make one good idea work for all our schools and every student, one would think that by now we would have realized the problems that attempting such a thing causes. I also don’t know how I feel about the charter schools, yes I believe that we should have choice, but I don’t believe that families should have to pay to receive a good education. It seems like perhaps we should focus on providing the funding and support to our existing (free, public) schools and making those schools worthy of our students and centers for higher learning.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

TWYH pgs 140-176

Abstract:
A lot happened in this section of the book, starting with the failure of Erin’s marriage and her unwillingness to tell anyone else what was happening. We then see the start of the Freedom Writers when she encourages not only herself, but her students to write diary entries about what is going on in their lives. With the help of John Tu she is able to print all the entries and the idea for a book is formed. The students then get the idea of taking their book to someone influential in DC. Once again, Erin manages to pull in favors and money from enough people to make the trip a reality and all 150 students fly out to DC and meet with the secretary of education. Upon their return they are greeted with a media frenzy over a recent murder committed by students and Erin decides to get their own story in the paper. After their story runs in the front page of the LA Times the offers for a television documentary pour in. They end up going with Connie Chung and at the insistence of her students Erin goes to the superintendent to stay with them their final year and accomplishes just that.
Reflection:
I’m not sure how Erin could have been so surprised at the dissolution of her marriage; she spent absolutely no time with him at all. I’m also a little put off by her calling her students “honey” and “sweetie,” and other pet names one usually reserves for family. It seems she oversteps all the boundaries of a teacher and is consistently rewarded for it. I get that in order to be effective teachers we need to step outside some lines and do what we can to reach out students, but I don’t think Erin’s example is necessarily that good of one. She also mentions in passing that he parents (plural) helped chaperone, yet we hear nothing of her relationship with her mother. It seems like if the people are not helping her with her students than they become nothing but a passing mention in her life.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

School Part 1

School is something I took for granted, I never thought as the movie mentioned that it would never have not been mandatory. But only a few large towns in the New England area required public schools, and only the privileged were sent to dame schools and only the rich continued past the basics and onto higher education. Granted, I knew that school did not always exist the way I knew it, but it still surprised me to see it. It wasn’t until Jefferson that someone fought for public schooling for all children. However, even he had the medieval view that only the kids who had the most aptitude should be allowed to continue on. The whole century just seemed so ridiculous; first not even feeling that education was important, and then what they educated. The spelling words that had no relevance to their daily lives, the twisted morals of becoming rich is the only way to be considered successful. Its seems funny to look back and think how stupid we were to subject our kids to this, and yet we are still implementing and encouraging outdated and harmful to our students.

Thursday, October 2, 2008

TWYH pgs 104-140

Abstract:
It is the start of the second year with the same students she had previously. Once again she runs into the issue of not being able to secure books for her students so she goes out and buys 150 copies each of four different books and presents them to the students in a Toast for Change ceremony. The students take the opportunity to propose a change in their lives, not just their academics. After reading The Diary of Anne Frank the students are very adamant about meeting Mies Giep, the woman who hid Anne and her family. They write letters to her and Erin manages to arrange a meeting with her. After the success of meeting Mies, they wish to meet Zlata from the next book they have read. And yet again Erin is able to pull it off, involving the parents and setting up a huge banquet for all her students and their parents and the guest of honor. Her students urge her to stay with them another year and in desperation she turns to the superintendent who manages to arrange it.
Reflection:
I certainly applaud all she does for her students and is able to accomplish, but there is no way I will ever have access to the sort of funds and connections she seems blessed to be able to do. It is almost disheartening in a way, knowing that I will not be able to get the authors of these books to come and see my students, we will not be meeting Mr. Spielberg and I will not be able to afford 600 brand new books. In addition to this it is very clear that Erin has no existence outside of teaching. And at the moment it is almost as if she is promoting this viewpoint, as if to say that only if you ignore your husband and entire life can you accomplish what I have with my students.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

TWYH pgs 61-103

Abstract:
In this section of the book we see the students actually get to meet Steven Spielberg and move on and become seniors. They beg her to try and move up with them, but the head of the department turns her down and accuses Erin of making the other teachers look bad. There are more signs that her marriage is not a good one when she mentions the awkwardness of having her students meet her husband for the first time and his interaction with them. Then a new school year begins and she has a new set of students with all their prejudices and inhibitions, and has to start over. She holds back a little and doesn’t take them on many field trips or extend herself as much as she did for the first set of students. Once Erin becomes aware of this she decides she needs to step it up a notch; that the class isn’t bonding because she is holding herself back. Luckily, it turns out she gets a chance to remedy this as several teachers are retiring and she can move up with her students as sophomores and continue to teach them.

Reflection:
I learned another thing about Erin that was not mentioned in the other novel, and that is that her parents are divorced. I vaguely recall wondering where her mother was during all this, but never really questioned it, yet this admission still does not explain her absence. It seemed this description of her first year with her new freshmen flew by, and it is hard to stop and think of something to reflect on because it seemed like just a few days have passed.
This part of the video was a lot less interesting to me as it focused less on what was going on in the schools themselves and more of what was going on with the board of education. Yes, that type of information was useful and it was nice to see the actual people involved in these landmark cases but it just didn’t draw me in like the previous portion. It felt more like a scene from my tenth grade history class when we covered those decades rather than a video I would be watching for teaching information and purposes. In fact the only things onscreen that really caught my eye were the bleak statistics on African American’s, Mexican American’s, and women’s graduation and higher education. There wasn’t the sense of the ludicrous, and completely opposite and frequently changing curriculum that was highlighted in the second section. Also, because it was not new information or highly detailed, it didn’t provide the same interest level either. In fact, I’m finding it very hard to reflect about this section at all because there isn’t anything that struck me about this section that seems worth delving into further.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

School Video Part 2 Reflection

The film certainly highlighted the fact that the school system swings from one extreme to another. They went from just the basics in crowded, overstuffed classes to Dewey’s introduction of a whole student education with all the resources being used and being able to accommodate many more students. I didn’t think this program looked that bad, students had the traditional “college bound” subjects but were also given more practical classes that could help them whether they went on to higher education or worked around the home.
One thing that threw me was that some schools taught in the dominant foreign language. I understand that as immigrants they may not know English, but what about the other immigrants who didn’t know the other foreign language?
From the progressive schools education took a huge swing back in the opposite direction with Coverly’s introduction of tracking students into either college bound classes or classes that would prepare them for a hands-on career. I can’t even express how ridiculous the idea is, but then again, the shift to all those life classes on how to kiss, and proper manners and the like, seems absolutely surreal as well.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Generations Article Review

“Talking About Their Generations”
Abstract:
The article mainly focused on defining the generations and their main traits as parents, teachers, and members of the educational community. They centered on the latest four generations; the Silents, the Boomers, the Gen-Xs, and my generation, the Millennials. For the most part the article defined the years that each generation influenced, and determined that the generation previous always seems to think less of the generation after. Essentially, they don’t trust the younger generation to get the job done right, and to make the world a better place. The second half of the article focused pretty much solely on the Millennials and the aspects that make up this particular generation. They mentioned and defined such aspects as sheltered, team players, pressured, conventional, and special. They identified misconceptions and presented the actual facts and figures. The article ended with a plea to administrators to recognize these aspects of the generation and be understanding of them.
Reflection:
While the article presented me with lots of information on the generations I either didn’t know or care to learn, it really didn’t provide me with any helpful information as an educator. The article seemed more of presenting the readers with information, or perhaps geared towards administrators instead. I’m not saying I don’t need to know this information; just that at the moment I’m looking more at information that can help me be a better teacher to my students. This aspect is severely lacking in the article, in fact, it does not present any ideas whatsoever on how to deal with each generation, it merely presents the information and warns us to take care to recognize one another’s differences when dealing with the educators of each generation. Like I said, the information was new and slightly helpful, I just feel that the article would have been more worth the read had it actually presented some solutions and suggestions.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

TWYH Pgs 36-61

Abstract:
In this section of the book we see Erin take the students to see Schindler’s List at a theater in her neighborhood; and the reaction is not one that she expected. The locals stop and stare, clutch their belongings in fear, and even leave. The reactions are the same and indeed even worse when they go to a restaurant afterwards. The incident is then covered by a local newspaper which mistakenly inserts Erin’s own home number, and she receives a frightening amount of hateful calls. A few of her neighbors, who unfortunately seem to be in the minority, reach out to her to provide help and support. One of these people, an old friend sets Erin and her class up to meet the author of the book that Schindler’s List was based on, and from there she manages to be put in touch with Steven Spielberg’s assistant who asks Erin to write a letter to Spielberg. The letter catches his attention and he sets up a meeting with Erin and the section ends with him requesting to meet her students.
Reflection:
Like Erin I was shocked and dismayed at the reactions to the students being in her section of the neighborhood. Even though I myself have not been exposed to much diversity, I still can recognize that we are all human and that skin can be many colors. I don’t judge a person by their skin color and it was something I was always taught was wrong. I know these events happened during a very tense and racially charged period in time in California, but that is no excuse for treating one another in such a manner. This section is rather hard to reflect on in terms of looking at it from an educational viewpoint. Right now my thoughts are almost centered on Erin as a “character” and not as this teacher who really did this. My thoughts run towards an impending divorce, not only because I know it is going to happen, but because there are little hints thrown in about the lack of support and interest from her husband. But to be fair this section also was more Erin centered rather than what Erin taught focused.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Diversity Article Synthesis

Abstract:
This article was about the correlation between diversity and learning styles. It highlighted the research done to examine the similarities and differences between cultures and learning styles. In this article there is the controversy of assuming that students with the same culture are going to have the same learning styles but that it could lead to stereotyping. The idea of knowing each student, including their background and culture is emphasized because of the importance in using several different teaching strategies. Guild did a study observing Mexican Americans, African Americans, Native Americans, and white Americans. She notes how there was a link between members of each group and their learning styles. For example, most Native Americans preferred quiet time in the classroom, while most African Americans preferred group discussions. Several differing opinions are then offered on approaching culture as it pertains to learning. Some believe that it should be a key component of differentiation, others feel that overestimation of this aspect could distract from other fundamentals of education. As the debate continues, the important thing to remember is that all children learn differently, whether due to culture or just individually and as teachers we much accommodate for all those different styles.

Reflection:
As a class we all seemed to feel that the article bordered on the offensive when it implied that members of certain cultures will all behave the same and have the same learning styles. While we did agree that there are general commonalities that can sometimes be assumed, we thought it presumptuous to place such stereotypical stigmas on the students. Many of us also thought the overall message of the article a little stale. That is, we as future educators are aware that our students have different learning styles, and that this is not just due to the fact that they have different cultural backgrounds, but that every individual is unique and thus their learning styles are equally unique and different from one another. Many of us also picked up on the suggestion that schools be segregated by culture and found the idea rather alarming and very outdated. Despite these differences in agreement and rather negative reactions, there were a few positive associations and one issue that everyone seemed to agree on with the article. The first being that we as teachers need to be aware that our students have different learning styles and perhaps even different cultural backgrounds and emphasis than us. The other idea, that everyone picked up on was that education seems to do things “all or nothing.” When one idea is presented that is logical and relevant they throw all their resources and energy into enacting that one idea, ignoring all the other useful and helpful ideas that have also worked. the article, and we as a class agree, states that we cannot throw all our eggs into one basket, we must use a combination of things to find what works best for our students.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

TWYH 1-35

Abstract:
The novel started off with the introductory chapter from The Freedom Writers Diary, but continues from Erin’s perspective rather than the students. She details her history and past further, explaining how she met her husband, her living situation, and her childhood. It also reiterated a fact that I seem to either have missed or didn’t recall from the other novel—that she was just a student teacher during her first semester at the school. The memoir also goes into more specifics and names and experiences that only she experienced or that she experienced with a select few individuals. One example would be when she drove a small group of students through the section of Long Beach that she had never been through.

Reflection:
The story is really just beginning, and much of it is repetitive from Freedom Writers, so there wasn’t too much that really jumped out at me and made me want to comment. However as previously mentioned I wasn’t aware of the fact that she was a student teacher and doing all this with only the expectation of being there for only one semester. It’s inspiring when my own student teaching is fast approaching. It is also a bit troublesome to read her experiences though, as hers is a daunting legacy to try and emulate. Sure I will not be faced with the same situation as her, or the same type of students, but will I be able to create such a lasting impression as she did? And will I even get the chance to do so?

Diversity Article Abstract and Reflection

Abstract:
The article The Culture/ Learning Style Connection: Educating for Diversity focused on the fact that there are differences in the learning styles and the emphasis on learning in different cultures. The article goes back and forth on whether teachers should focus and teach to these differences or not, and arrives at no definable conclusion. It does present accepted truths, such as that there are visible differences in cultures, but that there are differences between all individuals; and they present arguments from both sides on whether we as educators should devote our energy teaching to these differences. They article concludes by stating that education has a tendency to go from one extreme to the other and apply one thing that works to every student, and that perhaps a moderate combination and the realization that these differences exist is the best course for now.
Reflection:
There was nothing the article stated that I could disagree with, it stayed effectively neutral and really did not present an argument or even a very new idea. The fact that students have different learning styles seems obvious to me, every student is an individual, and as such they are different. Even members of the same cultural background are going to have differences.