Thursday, November 20, 2008

Students at Bat Reflection

Abstract:
”Students at Bat” pointed out the numerous ways we take responsibility away from students and then become frustrated when they won’t take responsibility the few times we allow. It explores who, parents or educators, should be the ones to instill this very important skill in students, and ways in which we teachers can provide students with opportunities to step up and take responsibility during their education. It goes on to say that students are not learning this valuable skill because we take away their learning opportunities and they are not as prepared for life as they should be. They conclude by saying that giving students increased responsibility and choice will help spark more interest in school.
Reflection:
I completely agree with this article. Society as a whole has become more protective of our children, not only in the case of their safety, but this has ended up with us not allowing them to make any mistakes. We decide everything for them, not allowing them to make their own choices to learn how to be responsible, everything is handed to them and there is little value in it.

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Personal Philosophy Reflection

As with anything in my life my philosophy will affect how I view things and how I arrange my life. It only makes sense that it would also affect how I intend on running my classroom. I have no set view for how my classroom is going to be organized, and I don’t intend on having a set arrangement, depending on what we are doing and who the students need to interact with is how the classroom will be arranged. Again with discipline and assessment it entirely depends on what the students are doing and what will best reflect their learning or best suit whatever “crime” it is they have done. The same really can be said for all the categories. I don’t intend on having a set way of teaching or of doing anything, I intend to completely tailor it to my students and our curriculum.

Alternative Schools

Alternative schools was the topic for last Thursday’s presentation, and they discussed charter schools, religious schools, and this funky school called Summerhill. There was a lot to discuss as most of us had not even heard of charter schools until enrolling in UMF. There wasn’t a whole lot of time left to discuss Summerhill and what the implications of having a school like that might do for a child’s education, and whether it could work elsewhere. I think it would have been nice to see more on the effects on education these alternative schools have, have they proven more effective, or to turn out more well rounded individuals. Even though I know stats cannot adequately display a child’s learning it’s nice to have something concrete to look at every once in awhile. Other than that it was nice to learn about those alternatives to public school that are out there if only for the simple fact that it’s a topic that I have never explored before.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Voices Reflection

The biggest thing I noticed about Voices is that everyone has a different idea of what an education should entail and how it should be delivered. They mainly fall into two categories—those that wish to revolutionize some form of education and take a radically new approach ( which may in fact be logical and necessary), and those wishing to seemingly go back to the days of Plato with only slight variations. This is of course a great simplification of the many ideas presented, and there were the few completely radical individuals. But for the most part I feel that education and the philosophies have followed a trend of bucking their predecessor’s ideas and thus creating a sort of cyclic effect with no real new changes being exacted because no one has taken the time to try to incorporate everyone’s good ideas into one philosophy. I’ve said it before in blogs and I’ll say it again, no one person and philosophy can solve everything, we need to merge and blend to create a truly diverse ideology. The problem with that is the same with politics, no one seems to want to compromise, it’s all or nothing.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Discipline Presentation Blog

Discipline is a highly controversial subject and this presentation did a very good job of getting across the ambiguity of what discipline is most effective. It was also interesting to see the video on the school that still allowed corporal punishment and the effects it had on that particular school environment. The discussion it generated was also enlightening and well worth the extra time we took. There weren’t any concrete rules or guidelines given, if anything we came away with less solid ideas on what is fair and unfair. And while we may form our own ideas about what equates a just and deserving disciplinary action we are not always guaranteed to have the backing of the school district which may already have a set of rules we are supposed to follow.